Best VPN for WhatsApp 2026 – 7 Tested Picks

Best VPN for WhatsApp

Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you make a purchase through them, at no additional cost to you.

For WhatsApp users in 2026, NordVPN is the best overall VPN for combining fast mobile performance, strong privacy tools, obfuscated servers, and reliable all-round usability. ExpressVPN is the best premium alternative for WhatsApp calls, while Windscribe, Proton VPN, Astrill VPN, Mullvad, and IVPN are strong backup choices for users who need privacy, stable messaging, VoIP support, and access on restrictive networks. The right VPN angle for WhatsApp is stable calls + public Wi-Fi protection + obfuscation + privacy + responsible use.

WhatsApp is one of the most widely used messaging apps in the world, but it does not work the same way on every network. Some users only need it for everyday messages, while others depend on it for voice calls, video calls, family communication, business chats, travel, customer support, group coordination, or international calling. In those cases, a VPN can help protect your connection on public Wi-Fi, reduce local network visibility, and sometimes help when WhatsApp or VoIP traffic is restricted by a country, school, workplace, hotel, or ISP.

The best VPN for WhatsApp should be fast enough for voice and video calls, stable on mobile networks, easy to use on iPhone and Android, and resilient enough for restrictive networks. It should support modern protocols like WireGuard or a fast provider-specific protocol, include a reliable VPN kill switch, protect against DNS leaks, and ideally include obfuscation or stealth features for networks that block VPN traffic. For this list, NordVPN and ExpressVPN take the top two spots because they are the best all-round choices for most WhatsApp users. You can also read our full NordVPN review and ExpressVPN review for deeper provider-level analysis.

Important WhatsApp note: A VPN can help with privacy, public Wi-Fi security, travel, and access on restrictive networks, but it should not be used to violate local laws, harass users, automate spam, impersonate others, or bypass platform rules. VPN performance can change quickly in countries or networks that block VoIP or VPN traffic, so install and test backup options before you need them.
Messaging privacy note: WhatsApp uses end-to-end encryption for personal messages and calls, but a VPN still helps protect your broader network connection. A VPN can hide traffic from local Wi-Fi observers and reduce ISP-level visibility, but it does not replace strong account security, two-step verification, updated devices, safe links, and careful backup settings.

Best VPN for WhatsApp in 2026: Quick Comparison

Rank VPN Best For Why It Works Well for WhatsApp
1 NordVPN Best overall VPN for WhatsApp Fast NordLynx protocol, obfuscated servers, strong security features, audited no-logs policy, and reliable mobile apps.
2 ExpressVPN Best premium VPN for WhatsApp calls Simple apps, strong privacy audits, RAM-only server architecture, router support, and consistent performance for voice/video calls.
3 Windscribe Best unusual anti-censorship VPN for WhatsApp Stealth and censorship-circumvention options, flexible apps, unlimited connections, and strong backup value on restrictive networks.
4 Proton VPN Best privacy-focused free/paid VPN for WhatsApp Stealth protocol, strong privacy reputation, good free/paid ecosystem, and a clear anti-censorship mission.
5 Astrill VPN Best stealth backup VPN for WhatsApp StealthVPN and OpenWeb-style protocol options make it useful for countries or networks that block VoIP and VPN traffic.
6 Mullvad Best anonymous privacy VPN for WhatsApp No email required, anonymous account numbers, transparent pricing, WireGuard support, and privacy-first design.
7 IVPN Best technical privacy VPN for WhatsApp Open-source apps, no email required, WireGuard support, strong transparency, and advanced privacy controls for technical users.

Why You Might Need a VPN for WhatsApp

A VPN can be useful for WhatsApp users for several practical reasons. First, WhatsApp is often used on public and shared networks: airports, hotels, cafés, universities, coworking spaces, libraries, shopping centers, apartments, and mobile hotspots. These networks are convenient, but they are not always secure. A VPN encrypts traffic between your device and the VPN server, reducing what other people on the same network can see. If you regularly connect outside your home network, our guide to fixing a VPN not working on public Wi-Fi is also useful.

Second, WhatsApp voice and video calls can be restricted on some networks. Schools, workplaces, hotels, mobile networks, or countries with VoIP restrictions may interfere with WhatsApp calls even when ordinary messages still work. A VPN with strong mobile performance and obfuscation features can help create a more private encrypted tunnel and may help users connect more reliably.

Third, a VPN helps reduce ISP-level and local network visibility. WhatsApp messages and calls are end-to-end encrypted, but your network provider may still see that you are connecting to WhatsApp-related services or other internet destinations. A VPN cannot hide activity from WhatsApp itself while you are using the app, but it can reduce what your ISP, hotel Wi-Fi provider, campus network, or public hotspot can see about your general internet traffic. For more detail, read our guide on whether internet providers can see your history with a VPN.

Fourth, travelers often depend on WhatsApp for family, business, banking alerts, taxis, hotels, support chats, and emergency contact. If you travel through countries or networks where WhatsApp is unreliable, a VPN can be part of a safer communications setup. The key is to install and test the VPN before you need it.

Fifth, DNS leak protection matters. Even if your VPN connects, poor DNS handling can expose browsing information outside the encrypted tunnel. WhatsApp users who care about privacy should choose VPNs with strong DNS leak protection, especially on public Wi-Fi, hotel networks, university networks, and shared connections.

How We Chose the Best WhatsApp VPNs

This ranking focuses on real-world WhatsApp usefulness rather than just brand popularity. For a broader explanation of our evaluation process, see our guide on how we test VPN services. The most important criteria were:

  • Voice and video call stability: A VPN for WhatsApp should be fast and stable enough for calls, not just text messages.
  • Mobile performance: WhatsApp is primarily used on phones, so iOS and Android performance matters more than desktop-only benchmarks.
  • Restrictive-network support: Preference was given to VPNs with obfuscated servers, stealth protocols, alternative routing, or anti-censorship features.
  • Speed: WhatsApp calls need low latency and stable throughput. If a VPN slows your connection too much, see our guide to VPN slow internet issues.
  • Privacy: Preference was given to providers with no-logs policies, audits, transparency reports, or strong technical safeguards. You can learn more in our guide to no-logs policies.
  • Ease of use: The best options should work well on Windows, macOS, iOS, Android, routers, and browser extensions. If you run into mobile issues, see our guides for VPN not working on iPhone and VPN not working on Android.
  • Backup value: In restrictive countries or VoIP-blocking networks, one VPN may work one week and fail the next. The safest setup is often to install two or three reliable options before arrival.

1. NordVPN — Best VPN for WhatsApp Overall

#1 Best Overall

NordVPN Windows app for WhatsApp

NordVPN is the best VPN for WhatsApp in 2026 because it offers the strongest balance of speed, privacy, usability, and restrictive-network features. WhatsApp users need a VPN that is fast enough for calls, simple enough for mobile users, and resilient enough for public Wi-Fi, hotel networks, school networks, workplace guest Wi-Fi, and countries where VoIP apps may be restricted.

The biggest advantage of NordVPN is balance. It has fast modern VPN protocols, strong encryption, a kill switch, DNS leak protection, split tunneling, threat protection features, obfuscated servers, Double VPN, and broad device support. For WhatsApp users, NordLynx helps with speed, while obfuscated servers can be useful on networks that block ordinary VPN traffic.

NordVPN is also a strong option for people who care about verified privacy claims. Its no-logs policy has been independently reviewed multiple times, and the provider has invested heavily in server security and infrastructure transparency. For most users, that matters more than picking a small VPN with minimal support or inconsistent apps. For a deeper provider breakdown, read our NordVPN review.

For WhatsApp specifically, NordVPN is a practical first choice because it is easy to install, works well on mobile, and gives users enough troubleshooting options for difficult networks. If WhatsApp calls fail while the VPN is enabled, try a nearby server, switch protocol, use mobile data instead of Wi-Fi, or test obfuscated servers. If you ever have connection issues, see our guide on how to fix NordVPN not working.

Pros
  • Best overall VPN for WhatsApp
  • Fast NordLynx protocol for calls and mobile use
  • Obfuscated servers for restrictive networks
  • Strong privacy and security features
  • Audited no-logs policy
  • Good apps for beginners and advanced users
Cons
  • Obfuscated servers may require switching protocol settings
  • No VPN can guarantee WhatsApp access on every network
  • Renewal pricing can be higher than intro offers

Best for: Most WhatsApp users, travelers, students, remote workers, expats, families, and anyone who wants a polished VPN with strong mobile performance.

Visit NordVPN

2. ExpressVPN — Best Premium VPN for WhatsApp Calls

#2 Premium Pick

ExpressVPN Windows app for WhatsApp

ExpressVPN is the best premium alternative for WhatsApp users who want a simple, polished VPN with strong apps and minimal configuration. It is not the cheapest VPN, but it remains one of the easiest mainstream VPNs to recommend to non-technical users who want a clean interface and reliable privacy features.

The main selling point is consistency and usability. ExpressVPN’s apps are simple, the connection process is fast, and the provider has a strong reputation for working across many different networks. This is valuable for WhatsApp because users may move between home Wi-Fi, mobile data, hotel Wi-Fi, school networks, work networks, airports, and public hotspots.

ExpressVPN also uses RAM-only server technology, meaning servers are designed so that data is not written permanently to hard drives. Combined with its no-logs policy and independent audits, that makes ExpressVPN one of the most credible mainstream VPNs for privacy-conscious users. For more detail, see our ExpressVPN review.

For WhatsApp calls, ExpressVPN is best if you want a premium VPN that requires less manual tuning than more technical providers. If calls fail, test nearby servers, switch between Wi-Fi and mobile data, restart WhatsApp, or try another protocol. If ExpressVPN does not work as expected, our guide on how to fix ExpressVPN not working covers common fixes.

Pros
  • Very easy to use
  • Excellent premium apps
  • Good for WhatsApp voice and video calls
  • Strong router support
  • RAM-only server architecture
  • Strong independent audit history
Cons
  • More expensive than many competitors
  • No VPN can guarantee constant access on VoIP-blocking networks
  • Fewer advanced settings than technical VPNs

Best for: WhatsApp users who want a simple, premium VPN for calls, travel, public Wi-Fi, browsing, messaging, and everyday security.

Visit ExpressVPN

3. Windscribe — Best Unusual Anti-Censorship VPN for WhatsApp

Anti-Censorship Pick

Windscribe Windows app for WhatsApp

Windscribe is one of the strongest unusual VPN choices for WhatsApp because it has a better anti-censorship angle than most generic VPNs. It is flexible, configurable, and useful as a backup on networks that block WhatsApp calls, VoIP traffic, or ordinary VPN connections.

The reason Windscribe works well for WhatsApp users is flexibility. If a normal VPN connection fails, users may be able to test stealth-style options, different ports, WStunnel-style approaches, or alternative connection methods. This makes Windscribe a practical backup VPN in countries or networks where restrictions can change quickly.

Windscribe is also useful because of its generous device policy. Users who need WhatsApp on phones, laptops, tablets, browser sessions, and travel devices may prefer a VPN that does not feel restrictive. This is especially useful for families, students, creators, remote workers, and travelers.

The main limitation is that Windscribe can feel quirky compared to NordVPN or ExpressVPN. Some users may need to experiment with protocol settings before finding a stable connection. But for WhatsApp, that flexibility is a strength rather than a weakness.

Pros
  • Best unusual anti-censorship VPN for WhatsApp
  • Useful stealth and censorship-circumvention options
  • Unlimited device connections on paid plans
  • Good browser extensions
  • Flexible privacy and blocking tools
  • Strong backup VPN profile
Cons
  • Interface may feel quirky compared to NordVPN or ExpressVPN
  • Call performance can vary by server and protocol
  • May require manual protocol testing
  • No VPN can guarantee constant WhatsApp access everywhere

Best for: WhatsApp users who want a flexible anti-censorship VPN with useful backup value, many devices, and strong privacy tools.

Visit Windscribe

4. Proton VPN — Best Privacy-Focused Free/Paid VPN for WhatsApp

Privacy + Stealth Pick

Proton VPN Windows app for WhatsApp

Proton VPN is a strong choice for WhatsApp because it combines a privacy-first brand with anti-censorship features. Its Stealth protocol is designed to disguise VPN traffic so it looks less like ordinary VPN traffic, which is exactly the type of feature users should look for when WhatsApp or VoIP traffic is restricted.

Proton VPN is also attractive because it has a broader privacy ecosystem. Users who already trust Proton Mail or Proton’s privacy products may prefer Proton VPN over more marketing-heavy VPN brands. The apps are clean, the privacy positioning is strong, and the provider has a clear anti-censorship mission.

For WhatsApp, Proton VPN is best used as a privacy-focused main VPN or backup alternative to NordVPN, ExpressVPN, or Windscribe. It is especially useful if you want a provider with both free and paid options, a strong reputation, and a protocol built specifically for VPN-blocking environments.

The main limitation is that free VPN performance may not be enough for heavy voice or video calling, and availability can change in restrictive countries. As with every WhatsApp VPN, install it before travel and keep backup options ready.

Pros
  • Stealth protocol for censorship resistance
  • Strong privacy reputation
  • Good free and paid ecosystem
  • Clean apps
  • Useful backup option for restrictive networks
  • Strong fit for Proton Mail users
Cons
  • Free plan may be too limited for heavy video calling
  • Performance can vary in restrictive environments
  • Not always as simple as ExpressVPN
  • No VPN can guarantee constant WhatsApp access everywhere

Best for: WhatsApp users who want a privacy-focused VPN with stealth features, free/paid options, and a strong anti-censorship mission.

Visit Proton VPN

5. Astrill VPN — Best Stealth Backup VPN for WhatsApp

Stealth Backup Pick

Astrill VPN

Astrill VPN is one of the most important stealth-focused VPNs to consider for WhatsApp in countries or networks that block VoIP traffic. It is not cheap, and it is not the best everyday VPN for casual users. But when the priority is restrictive-network resilience, Astrill becomes much easier to justify.

Astrill is known for proprietary connection methods such as StealthVPN and OpenWeb-style protocols. These are designed for situations where ordinary VPN traffic may be detected or blocked. That makes Astrill useful as a backup option when standard VPN apps struggle with WhatsApp calls.

For WhatsApp, Astrill is best treated as a specialized fallback VPN rather than the default recommendation for everyone. NordVPN and ExpressVPN are easier to recommend as mainstream first choices, while Windscribe and Proton VPN are stronger privacy/anti-censorship alternatives. Astrill fills the role of a high-cost stealth backup.

The tradeoff is price and interface. Astrill is expensive compared to many VPNs, and it may feel more technical than modern mainstream apps. Still, for travelers, expats, journalists, students, remote workers, and users who need a serious backup, Astrill deserves a spot.

Pros
  • Strong stealth-focused backup VPN
  • StealthVPN-style traffic obfuscation
  • OpenWeb-style protocol options
  • Useful when ordinary VPNs fail
  • Good for restrictive-network troubleshooting
Cons
  • Expensive compared to most VPNs
  • Less polished than NordVPN or ExpressVPN
  • Not the best value for casual users
  • No VPN can guarantee constant WhatsApp access everywhere

Best for: WhatsApp users, travelers, expats, journalists, business users, and anyone who wants a dedicated stealth-focused backup VPN.

Visit Astrill VPN

6. Mullvad — Best Anonymous Privacy VPN for WhatsApp

Anonymous Privacy Pick

Mullvad VPN

Mullvad is one of the best privacy-first VPN choices for WhatsApp users who care more about anonymity and account minimization than streaming libraries or marketing extras. It is not trying to be the flashiest VPN. Instead, Mullvad focuses on clean apps, transparent pricing, and minimizing the information it collects about customers.

The standout feature is Mullvad’s account system. Instead of signing up with an email address and password, you generate an account number. This makes Mullvad feel very different from most commercial VPNs. It is ideal for users who dislike handing over personal information just to buy privacy software.

Mullvad is also attractive because of its simple flat pricing. There are no confusing long-term discounts, countdown timers, or aggressive upsells. You pay for the service and get the same product as everyone else.

For WhatsApp, Mullvad is best if your main priority is privacy and you are comfortable with a less mainstream provider. It may not be as WhatsApp/VoIP-focused as Windscribe or Proton VPN, and it is not as beginner-friendly as NordVPN, but it is a strong option for users who value anonymity and technical transparency.

Pros
  • No email address required
  • Anonymous account number system
  • Flat transparent pricing
  • Strong privacy culture
  • Good for privacy-focused browsing
  • Clean, minimal apps
Cons
  • Not the most WhatsApp/VoIP-focused option
  • No live chat support
  • Less beginner-friendly for some users
  • Access reliability may vary in restrictive environments

Best for: WhatsApp users who want privacy-first VPN protection with minimal account data and no gimmicks.

Visit Mullvad

7. IVPN — Best Technical Privacy VPN for WhatsApp

Technical Privacy Pick

IVPN

IVPN is another excellent but less mainstream VPN. It is a strong choice for WhatsApp users who want a privacy-focused service with open-source apps, clear policies, and fewer marketing distractions.

Like Mullvad, IVPN does not require an email address to create an account. This is a major advantage if your goal is to reduce the amount of personal information connected to your VPN subscription. IVPN also offers WireGuard, a kill switch, tracker blocking, and multi-hop functionality on supported plans.

IVPN is most interesting for WhatsApp when the user is more technical. It is not the most mainstream travel VPN, but it has a serious privacy profile and technical features that appeal to users who understand protocols, multi-hop, DNS leak protection, and manual troubleshooting.

The tradeoff is simplicity. IVPN is not as polished for casual users as NordVPN or ExpressVPN, and it is not as WhatsApp/VoIP-branded as Windscribe or Proton VPN. But it is a credible technical privacy option for people who want a serious backup VPN.

Pros
  • No email required for signup
  • Open-source apps
  • Strong privacy positioning
  • WireGuard support
  • Multi-hop available on Pro plan
  • Good for technical privacy users
Cons
  • More expensive than budget VPNs
  • Smaller server network
  • Less polished than NordVPN or ExpressVPN
  • May require more manual troubleshooting on restrictive networks

Best for: WhatsApp users who want a technical privacy VPN with clean apps, transparency, and minimal data collection.

Visit IVPN

Best VPN for WhatsApp by Use Case

Use Case Best Choice Why
Best overall VPN for WhatsApp NordVPN Best balance of speed, mobile apps, privacy, obfuscation, and ease of use.
Best premium VPN for WhatsApp calls ExpressVPN Simple apps, strong audits, router support, and premium usability for calls and travel.
Best unusual anti-censorship VPN Windscribe Flexible apps, stealth options, and strong backup value on restrictive networks.
Best privacy-focused free/paid VPN Proton VPN Stealth protocol, free/paid options, and strong privacy ecosystem.
Best stealth backup VPN Astrill VPN StealthVPN and OpenWeb-style options make it a useful restrictive-network backup.
Best anonymous privacy VPN Mullvad No email required, anonymous account numbers, and transparent pricing.
Best technical privacy VPN IVPN Open-source apps, no email signup, and technical privacy controls.

VPN Tips for WhatsApp Users

Use a nearby VPN server for better call quality

WhatsApp voice and video calls are sensitive to latency. Start with a nearby VPN server in your country or region. If calls stutter, drop, or sound delayed, switch to a closer server before assuming the VPN does not work.

Use WireGuard or the provider’s fastest protocol

For most WhatsApp users, WireGuard or a WireGuard-based protocol will provide the best speed and responsiveness. NordVPN uses NordLynx, ExpressVPN uses Lightway, and many privacy-focused VPNs support WireGuard directly. For a broader comparison, read our guide to VPN protocols.

Try mobile data if public Wi-Fi blocks calls

If WhatsApp calls fail on hotel, school, workplace, or café Wi-Fi, test mobile data. Some local Wi-Fi networks block VoIP traffic, while mobile networks may behave differently. If mobile data works but Wi-Fi does not, the local network is probably part of the problem.

Use obfuscated or stealth modes on restrictive networks

Ordinary VPN traffic may be easier to detect and block on restrictive networks. Use obfuscated servers, StealthVPN, OpenWeb-style modes, Stealth protocol, WStunnel-style options, or other censorship-resistant modes when available.

Turn on the kill switch carefully

A kill switch blocks internet traffic if the VPN disconnects unexpectedly. This is good for privacy, but it may also interrupt WhatsApp calls if the VPN drops. Use it when privacy matters most, and test how your VPN behaves before relying on it for important calls.

Use split tunneling when needed

Split tunneling can help if WhatsApp works better outside the VPN but you still want to protect browsers, email, banking, or other apps. However, in restrictive countries, split tunneling should be used carefully because apps outside the VPN connect directly through the local network.

Fix connection problems before switching VPNs

If WhatsApp fails with a VPN, try different protocols, different servers, mobile data instead of Wi-Fi, obfuscated mode, TCP instead of UDP, or a different region. If the VPN connects but nothing loads, see our guide to fixing a VPN connected but no internet issue. If it repeatedly drops, see why a VPN keeps disconnecting.

Which WhatsApp VPN Should You Choose?

Choose NordVPN if you want the best overall mainstream VPN for WhatsApp. It is the safest first recommendation for most users because it combines speed, mobile performance, privacy, obfuscated servers, strong apps, and good security tools.

Choose ExpressVPN if you want a premium VPN that is extremely easy to use and very consistent across phones, laptops, routers, mobile data, and changing network conditions.

Choose Windscribe if you want a flexible anti-censorship VPN with stealth options, many device connections, and strong backup value.

Choose Proton VPN if you want a privacy-first VPN with Stealth protocol, free/paid options, and a strong anti-censorship mission.

Choose Astrill VPN if you want a specialized stealth backup VPN and are willing to pay more for restrictive-network resilience.

Choose Mullvad if your top priority is anonymity and you like the idea of using a VPN without giving the provider your email address.

Choose IVPN if you want a clean, transparent, technical VPN with serious privacy values and less marketing noise.

Final Verdict: Best VPN for WhatsApp in 2026

The best VPN for WhatsApp in 2026 is NordVPN. It offers the best balance of mainstream usability, mobile speed, privacy, obfuscated servers, security features, and device support. It is the easiest first choice for most travelers, students, remote workers, expats, and everyday users who want stable WhatsApp messaging and calls on public or restrictive networks.

ExpressVPN is the best premium alternative if simplicity and call consistency matter more than price. Windscribe is the strongest unusual anti-censorship pick, Proton VPN is the best privacy-focused free/paid option, Astrill VPN is the best stealth backup, Mullvad is best for anonymous accounts, and IVPN is best for technical privacy users.

Get NordVPN Try ExpressVPN

FAQ: Best VPN for WhatsApp

What is the best VPN for WhatsApp?

NordVPN is the best VPN for WhatsApp overall because it offers the best combination of mobile speed, privacy, obfuscated servers, audited no-logs infrastructure, strong apps, and ease of use.

Does a VPN work with WhatsApp?

Yes, VPNs can work with WhatsApp, but performance depends on the provider, server distance, protocol, mobile network quality, Wi-Fi restrictions, and whether the network blocks VoIP or VPN traffic.

Can a VPN help with WhatsApp calls?

A VPN may help if WhatsApp calls are blocked or restricted on a local network. For best results, use a nearby server and a fast protocol. If calls are choppy, try another server or switch between Wi-Fi and mobile data.

Why does WhatsApp not work with my VPN?

WhatsApp may fail with a VPN because of server distance, blocked VPN traffic, DNS issues, weak Wi-Fi, mobile network restrictions, app cache problems, or VoIP blocking. Try another server, protocol, or obfuscated mode.

Is Windscribe good for WhatsApp?

Yes. Windscribe is a strong unusual VPN for WhatsApp because it offers flexible apps, stealth and censorship-circumvention options, unlimited connections on paid plans, and strong backup value on restrictive networks.

Is Proton VPN good for WhatsApp?

Proton VPN is a strong privacy-focused option for WhatsApp because it offers Stealth protocol, free and paid options, clean apps, and a broader anti-censorship mission.

Is Astrill VPN good for WhatsApp?

Astrill VPN can be a strong stealth backup option for WhatsApp because it offers StealthVPN and OpenWeb-style protocols designed for restrictive networks. It is expensive, but useful as a specialized fallback.

Should I use more than one VPN for WhatsApp in restrictive countries?

Yes. If you are traveling to or living in a country where WhatsApp, VoIP, or VPN traffic may be restricted, install at least two VPNs before you need them. A mainstream VPN plus an anti-censorship backup gives you more options.

Can a VPN make WhatsApp completely anonymous?

No. A VPN can hide your IP address from local networks and reduce ISP-level visibility, but it does not make WhatsApp completely anonymous. WhatsApp may still use your phone number, contacts, device signals, account data, and metadata.

Is using a VPN with WhatsApp legal?

VPN rules and enforcement vary by country, and this article is not legal advice. Always check current local rules, follow applicable laws, and use VPNs responsibly for privacy and security.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *